Looking to move to the Bay Island Area? Here are the Bay Island homes for sale! Bay Island is fantastic! I see you have great taste! The neighborhood is actually an island in Virginia Beach. Bay Island is only accessible by boat, or by West Great Neck Road. A big percentage of the homes are on the water near Broad Bay. The neighborhood is in the Cox School District. It is near Lynnhaven and Green Hill Farms. Play golf at Broad Bay Point Country Club. Shopping is located up and down Great Neck Rd and on Shore drive. Many excellent restaurants dot the area.